Events: Forbes Regal different Hoogewerf said data storage invisible rich (Figure)
| Event Details:
Comics: Welcome to the ranks of millionaires! CFP for Figure
(Reporter Heying Si, Li Yuan) has just released the 2011 Fortune magazine reported that the country 1 out of every 1400 people are millionaires. So how many millionaires in Guangzhou? Hoogewerf answer is 5.35 million.
However, this reporter will be last year's Forbes Hoogewerf and comparison of the data found that two agencies issued millionaires data "fight" people today. There are scholars in economics, that all real estate, personal property fully counted as wealth is not scientific, did not reflect the real wealth of personal ability.
Forbes and Hoogewerf data "fight"
Report Research Institute released the day before yesterday "2011 Fortune magazine reported," that there are 157,000 millionaires in Guangdong, where Guangzhou of Guangdong province in the most millionaires to reach 5.35 million, 4,300 more than last year.
Guangzhou's millionaires really are there so many? Reporters compared the wealthy Forbes published data, found that both the data in the "fight."
Forbes Chinese version of the previously issued "White Paper on China's private wealth", estimated in 2010 the number of millionaires in Mainland China reached 38.3 million, of which nearly 8 million people in Guangdong.
2010 Fortune magazine report, pointed out that Guangdong millionaires 14.5 million, and Forbes's a difference of nearly 1 times.
But reporters found inconsistencies between the statistical data. Report Research Institute according to the statement, "2011 Fortune magazine reported," the "rich people" the threshold to have more than ten million yuan of as_set_s, and this ten million yuan as_set_s, including as_set_s, unlisted companies, home real estate and art collection. Hoogewerf conference site also joked that if a house in Shanghai, with 3, is likely to reach the standards of millionaires.
The only statistics Forbes' private investable as_set_s, "including cash on hand, bank deposits, shares (only open in the secondary market valuation and trading of tradable shares and non-tradable shares), bonds, funds, fixed income financial products, investment real estate and other (such as gold, art and collectibles).
The most obvious difference is that Hurun list the unlisted companies, owner-occupied housing are also considered to personal wealth, but Forbes is limited to available investment as_set_s, including shares of listed companies, investment real estate.
Hoogewerf: Stealth is missed twice as rich
Hoogewerf even said that China still has "invisible rich." "2011 Fortune magazine report," estimated that about 200 wealthy country ten billion people, 97 of which the sun rich man, the "2010 China Rich List" tens of billions on the rich, the rest is invisible rich. Ten billion billionaires, the proportion of business owners accounted for 95% of the enterprises accounted for 80% of all as_set_s. They have a total value of 1 billion yuan of owner-occupied property, 10 million cars, and a collection of works of art worth $ 100 million. All the as_set_s of its investable as_set_s of 18%. Ten billion rich, 5% of "investors", may invest as_set_s of its 96% of all as_set_s. They have a total value of 1 billion yuan of owner-occupied property, 20 million cars, and a collection of works of art worth $ 300 million.
Last year, for the first time released the "2010 Guangdong Wealth Report", the Hoogewerf had said the results essentially from the sun rich, estimated the number to be missed twice as rich stealth. His team estimates that more than 10 billion yuan in Guangdong's richest 700 people. Hoogewerf also said that the most difficult to investigate in Dongguan, the proportion of missing or reach more than 1:3.
Expert: Statistical data of all as_set_s will be water
Lingnan Institute of Finance and tax department head Lin Jiang pointed out that different rich list have their own different caliber is normal, but he would prefer to calculate the "investable as_set_s", instead of all as_set_s.
"If all as_set_s are included, the data will lead to moisture, such as unlisted companies, what value is this to me?" Lin Jiang another example, if the property can not be made immediately with the "realization", such as self-occupied property, Another example is through the purchase of real estate loans, and personal wealth does not reflect the ability to "loan to buy a house buy a house with a one-time nature of payment is not the same."
"In the absence of published data sources, lack of government confirmed the case, accuracy will be discounted." Lin Jiang believes that all movable and immovable property are calculated into the practice and science is not accurate enough, easy to "exaggeration."
(Editor: High-fructose fruit) |
|
|