Maple Review Home
   Chinese Literature Society of North America | Maple Review | Immigrants in Canada | Angel Studio | The Driftwood Artist Society | Ocean of Poetry | Island of Music
"HuaHe Cup" 2007 Chinese Mainland and Oversea Poetry Competition and Non-governmental Magazines and Newspapers Joint Exhibition starts on the first day of 2007.
  
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister  ProfileProfile    Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Sign inSign in   BlogsBlogs    Weblogs NewsWeblogs News   AlbumAlbum 
English Home Bilingual Home Chinese Home
Dictionary Check Poems' Rules & Forms Search for Chinese Poems Poetry & Music

Maple Review Home -> 谈古论今 Post new topic   Reply to topic
请问凤凰优秀选手的评选标准是什么?!
孔小虎
秀才


Joined: 15 May 2007
Posts: 137
Location: 中国江苏南京
孔小虎Collection
PostPosted: 2012-12-23 20:54:24    Post subject: 请问凤凰优秀选手的评选标准是什么?! Reply with quote

请问优秀选手的评选标准是什么?!强烈建议重新确定获奖名单!

孔小虎


我研究了一下,这次获奖的部分写手是票数比较低的人,而且这些人在提名名单上就排在前面。里面还有去年的老面孔。
也就是说,投票是不做依据的,一开始就比较看好这些获奖的人。

既然不将票数作为评选标准,而且开始就“心中有数”,那还投什么票,这不是在戏弄人吗?我终于明白,为什么不把候选人名单公开发在论坛上的原因是什么了。

我排名第九,评不上十大优秀选手,倒能理解。那宜昌王坚3251票,这么高的票数也评不上,怎么解释?
凤凰的评选到底标准是什么?

其实,是否评得上是次要的,主要是应该讲一个公正和透明。
因为凤凰论坛自称是具有影响力的论坛,那就应该具备公信力。
这样的评选如何让人们信服?干脆直接内定算了,省得浪费大家的感谢与时间!这样的做法,还有人愿意为凤凰奉献有价值的文字吗?
我个人认为,评选应该根据作品的含金量和影响力,而不是按数量。

那些落选的人票数那么高,说明了什么?说明他们作品有影响力,说明人们认可他们,说明人们不是按名字的排列来判断的。
打个比方,评判一本书的价值,不应该是出版社的编辑,应该是读者。
因此,强烈建议重新确定获奖名单!
有错就该改,才是凤凰的真正风格!


Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
孔小虎
秀才


Joined: 15 May 2007
Posts: 137
Location: 中国江苏南京
孔小虎Collection
PostPosted: 2012-12-23 20:56:28    Post subject: Reply with quote

这是2012凤凰论坛的十大优秀写手名单

十大优秀写手(排名不分先后):
帝国良民
古月轩主
醉在江南
湖畔小子
维扬卧龙1
沙蒙
直隶巴人
曲静通幽
xy大漠飘雪
zhudodo
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Display posts from previous:   
Emoticons
Very Happy Smile Sad Surprised
Shocked Confused Cool Laughing
Mad Razz Embarassed Crying or Very sad
Evil or Very Mad Twisted Evil Rolling Eyes Wink
Exclamation Question Idea Arrow
View more Emoticons
Page 1 of 1           View previous topic View next topic    
Maple Review Home -> 谈古论今    Post new topic   Reply to topic
Jump to:  


Once you post your works here, that means you submits them to the magazine of Maple Review (North American Maple, or BeiMeiFeng), a bilingual journal published by Chinese Literature Society of North America. The magazine holds the right to translate them into Chinese, and publish them in both languages. You need to be responsible for the copyright issues of your own files uploaded.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
phpBB Chinese interface was translated by iCy-fLaME